主頁 高登熱話 吃喝玩樂 科技消費 名人專訪 短片
現有會員可[按此]登入。未成為會員可[按此]註冊。
[公司模式 - 關]  [懷舊模式 - 開
[Youtube 預覽 - 關]  [大字型]  [小字型]

您現在聚腳在 影視台內。

有關解封部份帳號之事宜

早前收到各會員反映一些朋友的帳號可能因誤會導致被封,CEO與管理員團隊商討後,重新審核並決定解封部分只輕微觸犯版規、懷疑被駭的帳號。所有可得到解封的帳號(包括登入電郵及備用電郵)將會收到我們發出的通知,如有用戶收到電郵而未能正常重新登入,可以到「聯絡我們」(http://forum8.hkgolden.com/contactus.aspx)提供你用作註冊的電郵地址、後備電郵地址予我們跟進。

香港高登討論區管理員團隊
精選文章
DeerGamer
跳至第

發起人
有冇人會睇新一套中途島
37 個回應
舊人翻新

同2006套珍珠港一樣, 夾硬插愛情線, 唔係好似五六十年代元祖版咁集中講兩軍心態, 唔係咁喜歡


#good2#1    #bad#0  
標籤:
導演拍開爛片
唔慌好睇[sosad]


無乜期待


戰爭片都係二戰剛完無耐的五六十年代最好睇


想睇受胎島多 d


仲諗住入場睇
好彩巴打們提醒[sosad]
慳返


謝謝提醒#adore#


導演作品

2004The Day After Tomorrow
200810,000 BC
20092012
2011Anonymous
2013White House Down
2015Stonewall
2016Independence Day: Resurgence
2019Midway


近10年最好睇戰爭片之尤其呢幾個月啲戲咁低水準


考慮中


8/10
Account of Crucial Naval Battle in Emmerich Style
3xHCCH29 October 2019

For its 2 hours 18 minute run, the story of the crucial naval battles and the heroism of its real-life protagonists were front and center here in "Midway." There were no fictional characters or cheesy love stories like in the first "Midway" film or "Pearl Harbor." While seeing some popular young actors like Criss or Jonas can be distracting, the all-star cast generally rendered honor and respect to the heroes they portrayed. Focusing on soldiers of lesser rank allowed for some intimate personal drama in actual battle situations, perhaps with not much depth as possible. As this movie is rated PG, so do not expect to see graphic injuries at the level of "Saving Private Ryan."

203 out of 253 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.


10/10
Best WW2 movie in decades
phd_travel7 November 2019

Finally there is a WW2 movie with the right balance of modern effects and good storytelling. I've always preferred the straightforward stories in Tora Tora Tora and A Bridge Too Far over the newer gory angst filled war movies and those which deal with obscure insignificant incidents. Unlike Bay's Pearl Harbor or the older Midway movie there is no wasted time on silly romances. Also the dragginess of Eastwood and the gore of Spielberg are not present here.

The screenplay is clear and comprehensive from pre Pearl Harbor to the decisive day everything is clearly explained. Doolittle deserves mention. Good history lesson for some folks nowadays who seem to forget which country was defending themselves against those who waged aggressive wars! Slower moments are not dull as they are used to explain strategy, training and the role of intelligence.

The air battle scenes and dive bombing scenes are thrilling yet clear. You can still see who is who. You are really put right into the center of things. Superb exciting cinematography without looking fake or too CGI.

The casting is brilliant. Using distinctive famous actors to portray the various heroes helps the viewer remember who is who and build up sympathy for whether they make it or not. Ed Skrein usually the anti hero type role. Here he plays the cocky pilot and his eventual vulnerability is touching. Luke Evans is convincing as another hero pilot. Patrick Wilson is perfect as the intelligence officer who helped get it right. The older actors like Denis Quaid and Aaron Eckhart are well cast too and Woody usually a goofball is fine. Actors usually don't associate with historic roles like Darren Criss and Jonas are surprisingly right. Mandy Moore looks pretty and suitable in her WW2 getup. Should do more roles from this period. The Japanese naval officers are distinctive enough to differentiate.

A truly international effort it took a German director, Chinese producers, an American writer and great British and American cast to make the best WW2 movie in decades.

62 out of 92 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.


本身諗住睇,依家不了


有啲呢套feel
導演都鍾意呢個風格

[電影] 點睇《庫爾斯克號》係咪近年最好睇海軍片?
https://forumd.hkgolden.com/view.aspx?message=7021918


其實套野應該唔差
imdb6.9分[sosad]


10/10
Excellent Movie and Historically Accurate
atomsmasher39 November 2019

This is an excellent historical portrayal of the Battle of Midway, and some of the events that led up to it. There is a lot of intensity throughout the film, and it shows how some of the decisions on both sides were truly a gamble in that time. There were no satellites, gps systems, or sophisticated radar systems. The only missing pieces to this movie, as noted by others, is the lack of US fighter planes. Maybe it is intended to focus mainly on the Dauntless pilots. I took my wife and kids to see this movie, as it seems much of the history of this country is being forgotten. I am so glad I did. The kids had no idea that any of this happened. As for the critics that wrote negative reviews and trashed this movie, I think attributes to a lot of what is wrong with this country today. People who decided not to see this movie, on Veterans Day weekend, based on the critics reviews, are truly missing an excellent movie. This movie is historically accurate, with no lame love story, or fictional substories.
49 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.


8/10
More than you'd expect
xhalonick9 November 2019

Critics are trashing this film, I went into it skeptical. After, I'm not so sure why. They tell a simplified story of the events leading up to, and eventually the battle of midway. You get to see two sides of life, the Japanese and the American forces. The script is fine, acting is pretty good in my opinion as well (shout out to Dennis Quaid, he is a great salty kinda guy). CGI was not that bad, especially for fast paced scenes. Only complaint is it is a bit long, which I understand due to how much they wanted to include. But there were 2-3 times I thought it might end, but there were still a few minutes left. In the end, a solid war movie that, in my opinion, does a great job showing some brutality of war, in addition to brothership and slice of life of the time. A solid film to honor the brave men and women that died for a better future.
35 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.


不可不Hi

當年2012幫大陸打飛機
搞到宜家大陸咁Hi Hi


2004The Day After Tomorrow

Budget $125 million[1]
Box office $544.3 million[1]

200810,000 BC

Budget $105 million
Box office $269.8 million

20092012

Budget $200 million[2]
Box office $769.7 million[3]


仲有邊D二戰一戰未拍過?


仲有邊D二戰一戰未拍過?
好難
midway 1976英國拍過


網評有雷/決戰中途島Midway,牛仔與職人| 電影| 噓!星聞
https://stars.udn.com/star/story/10090/4158266
2 days ago - 本文由網友小羊授權轉載我對軍武與戰史不熟,看這部片比較是抱著學習的心態,一方面想把以前沒好奇也沒了解的這段戰史建立一點視覺印象以供 ...

重疊的戰爭-決戰中途島〈Midway〉 @ 白色豆腐蛋糕:: 痞客邦::
https://kevinhearst.pixnet.net/blog/post/468788615-%E9%87%8D%E7%96%8A%E7%9A%84%E6%88%B0%E7%88%AD-%E6%B1%BA%E6%88%B0%E4%B8%AD%E9%80%94%E5%B3%B6%E3%80%88midway%E3%80%89
其次則是歷史,中途島一役的重要人物紛紛出現在這部電影裡面,巧妙穿插彼此的故事主線,有切斯特尼米茲指揮官(伍迪哈里遜飾演)、有情報專家艾德溫萊頓(派 ...

台美首週冠軍黑馬!《決戰中途島》Midway 還原二戰關鍵逆轉之 ...
2 days ago - 美國首週開片意外黑馬冠軍《決戰中途島》票房開出超出預期的好成績!連同步上映的台灣,也在全台開出逆轉成績,讓原本在週末前三名電影中放映 ...


最左17年前珍珠港

近10年仲起碼
永遠的0
山本五十六
日本最長的一天


永遠的0

[有劇透!] 永遠的零中伏區
https://forumd.hkgolden.com/view.aspx?message=5139102
陶傑評《永遠的0》
https://forumd.hkgolden.com/view.aspx?message=5155084

山本五十六

[電影] 點睇《山本五十六》又香川照之?
https://forumd.hkgolden.com/view.aspx?message=5474921
亂世中的常識人-山本五十六
https://forumd.hkgolden.com/view.aspx?message=5480600

日本最長的一天
時間差幾年 :o)


等一戰片1917算


跳至第



  快速回覆 - 輸入以下項目

本討論區現只接受會員張貼文章,本站會員請先登入。非會員人仕,您可以按此加入為新會員,費用全免,並可享用其他會員服務。


上次光臨時間: 8/12/2019 23:14
今天貼文總數: 559 | 累積文章數目: 6,598,929

聯絡我們 | 服務條款 | 私隱政策 | 廣告查詢 | 職位空缺
Copyright © 2019 HKGolden.com. All Rights Reserved.